I take my burgers seriously. By the same token, I’ll note the charms of In-N-Out Burger were lost on me the one time I had occasion to try a double double, which I know calls my burger street cred into question in some circles. This gastronomic lapse notwithstanding, my personal gold standard includes Bartley’s in Harvard Square, and O’Sullivan’s in Somerville, MA. Lanesboro’s Olde Forge serves a terrific burger as well, but there it’s mostly by way of accompanying their beer menu, for which any superlative is too faint praise.
Recently, The Lovely Wife, The Kid, and I visited Burger, the recently-opened spin off of Pittsfield’s Spice restaurant.
Burger’s decor called to mind an idealized fast food joint, with a central aisle for ordering, and a range of table, booth, and counter seating arrayed throughout a large, well-lit, and comfortable dining area. There were a few retro signs (a Coke-branded luncheonette sign, and other, similar adornments) hanging on the walls, but these were tastefully restrained, thematic accents rather than an indication of mistaking aggressive kitsch for design sensibility. Granted, the faux broken plaster and distressed brick near the back entrance was a bit cheesy, but I saw it as a sign of the pride the owners take in the work they have done renovating the building. That pride was apparent in the caliber of the service as well; from counter to table, it was efficient and friendly.
Now, the ideal burger must have a nice crust on the outside, while being rare and juicy on the inside. It should be mostly pink in the middle, but not so undercooked that the meat lacks texture. I’ll rarely say no to a nice slice of cheddar and a couple strips of crisp bacon on top of my burger, but when trying a new place, it’s best to let the sandwich speak for itself.
The Lovely Wife and The Kid chose to have their conversation with Burger’s Classic 1/4 Pound burger. TLW’s medium well burger was a bit overcooked for my taste, but that’s going to be true of any medium well burger anywhere. TK’s medium was more to my liking, as it held on to more of the beefy flavor that TLW sacrificed on the altar of doneness.
This being a special occasion, I opted for Burger’s Kobe burger. It came slightly less than the medium rare I ordered, which meant that the balance of juiciness to texture wasn’t where I prefer it to be, but it was still incredibly rich and flavorful. It was definitely worthwhile as both a curiosity and an indulgence, but ultimately, the classic burger acquits itself so well that there is little reason to indulge except to be indulgent.
While all the burgers were quite good, the real star of the show was the rolls. Most of the time, I take the roll — or the rye, in the case of a patty melt — for granted. It’s a mere container, a delivery system for the patty payload. If it’s doing its job, you don’t notice it. On either extreme however, the roll can make or break your burger. Bad bread can ruin an otherwise excellent slider. Great bread can elevate an average burger to heights undeserved on the merits of the meat itself. While Burger’s burgers are well above average, their rolls most definitely put them over the top.
The bread itself had a slight sweetness similar to a Portuguese roll. The inside was moist, with an almost steamed texture, while the outside was apparently finished on the grill, or on a grill press. The result was bread that adhered, almost melted into, the patty, while having a crisp texture on the outside.
For sides, we ordered plain french fries, chili cheese fries, and eggplant fries. TLW’s eggplant fries were the clear winner, and that’s coming from someone who usually prefers to avoid eggplant. They were light and crunchy without being greasy. The result was something that tasted like a glorious hybrid of french fry and onion ring.
The plain fries were nice (although next time, I might opt for the “dirty,” which I take to mean skin-on, variety), thick cut, crisp on the outside, fluffy on the inside. The only way these might be improved is by including a bottle of malt vinegar among the condiment options on each table. I’ve got nothing against good old ketchup, but chips this good and this substantial would be best with salt and vinegar.
The fries also served as a solid foundation for Burger’s chili cheese fries. The fries had the structural integrity required to support the mass of nicely flavorful chili, accompanied by straight-from-the-nozzle Technicolor orange processed cheese. Unfortunately, beside a hefty burger and a large milk shake, these fries were perhaps an exercise in undue optimism. They were very good, but more than I could handle. Next time, I believe I’ll opt for Burger’s sweet potato fries.
[Another suggestion: gravy for the fries, either alone, or as part of the classic gravy and cheese goo tandem affectionately known as Disco Fries.]
The shakes were merely all right. The consistency was nice — neither too milkily thin nor so thick you risk an aneurysm trying to suck it through the straw. I had a coffee shake, and the Lovely Wife and The Kid each opted for strawberry. Burger’s shakes weren’t overly sweet, which is nice. Too much syrup is often the unfortunate norm, and Burger avoided this pitfall. Our shakes were indeed coffee-esque and strawberry-ish, but I believe Burger accomplished this by using less syrup — and sacrificing flavor along with sweetness — rather than by using a syrup with a higher flavor to sweetener ratio.
For those for whom a burger just isn’t a burger without a cold beer alongside, Burger offered several varieties, as well as wine for more refined tastes. For those for whom wretched excess is an excellent starting place, Burger featured a range of spiked shakes that blend in various spirits along with the ice cream and other flavorings. The serving counter also boasted a tempting array of cookies, pastries, and other delectables for who prefer their decadence in solid, rather than liquid, form. I can offer no assessment of those, as we had a dessert date with some whoopie pies from Molly’s Bakery in North Adams (but that’s a story for another day).
Burger is located at 279 North Street in Pittsfield Massachusetts; 413-997-9797; www.eatatburger.com; open from 11:30 a.m. daily.